just keep giving him stuff i have cliff on the blue heart on summer 1st year i just gave him 1 bamboo shoot a day the 1 wild grape in summer

i honestly dont know but walk in at a random time and maybe u'll get lucky srry i cant help ;(

uhm... make sure that you've already had him apologize to you in the inn. if not, he won't give you the brooch.

there is a specific time you need to see him, if you are past the part where he apologives (tuesday thurrsday sunday at inn) then on mondays (6AM) make sure you have an empty space in your sack and eventually, one day he will come

you need a shelf... the largest rucksack is the eight-boxed, and you trigger the event when u come out of the house. just continue giving stuff. i experienced the event when his heart is green, just the day after the shelf arrives.

just keep giving him stff. mke him apologizE!!!!!!!!! THough he likes your dog....oh well,
see other peoples answer above.

If clift is in the game,choose him. His heart level comes up like a rocket. By the way, if
you don't marry clift on your 7th year-its game over. so, you shall not choose Gray. He is
boring, and very ****.Zzzzzzzzzzz.Huh? what was i talking about? ??? ?????????????