No you need the rose for it to and to have puppies its true no lie i tried it.

I put on a lily and my dog had a puppy. So you rong dude :|

Whether you put a rose on or a lily, just make sure they don't fight alot and don't walk
the female or take her for competitions. Only feed them dry food (or natural dog food bag)
and milk. Make sure they both have good personalities,too. And about 4-5 days the female
will get fat and to check the baby use a brush and look at her stomach, if it is kicking
there is a puppy :)

The rose says puts your dog in a romantic mood and the lily says very eye catching

Yes i think they both work i have a ros eon my female but i still cant tell wether shes
pregnant i think i might just chaange my dogs any good ideas of what dogs ? As they keep
fighting but they have wandeful personalities unless the female is saying atop im pregnant
or something ? :) xx