There are 40 Bronze Trophies, 5 Silver Trophies, 3 Gold Trophies, and 1 Platinum Trophy.
| Unlockable: | How to unlock: |
| ... And away he goes, Precious! (Bronze) | Defeat Gollum as Gollum. |
| A link to the elements. (Bronze) | Craft the Fire and Ice Bows. (Single Player Only) |
| A Wizard should know better! (Bronze) | Complete 'Osgiliath'. |
| An expected journey. (Bronze) | Travel to Trollshaws as Bilbo. |
| Dance of the dead. (Bronze) | Turn an enemy into a skeleton and make them dance. |
| Delved too greedily... (Bronze) | Collect more than 10,000,000,000 studs. (Single Player Only) |
| Don't tell the Elf... (Bronze) | Throw Gimli 30 times. |
| Great! ...Where are we going? (Bronze) | Form The Fellowship of the Ring. |
| Here's a pretty thing! (Silver) | Craft every Mithril item. (Single Player Only) |
| I told you he was tricksy. (Silver) | Collect all the Red Bricks. (Single Player Only) |
| I'm glad to be with you. (Bronze) | Complete a level in co-op. |
| I've always been taller! (Bronze) | Use the Ent Draught on Pippin. |
| It won't be that easy! (Bronze) | During 'Prologue', jump into the fires of Mount Doom as Isildur. |
| It's a dangerous business... (Bronze) | Complete 'The Black Rider'. |
| It's gone. (Bronze) | Complete 'Mount Doom'. |
| Let's hunt some Orc! (Bronze) | Complete 'Amon Hen'. |
| My Precious... (Gold) | Collect all the Mithril Bricks. (Single Player Only) |
| Naughty little fly... (Bronze) | Complete 'The Secret Stairs'. |
| Not with 10,000 men... (Silver) | Unlock all characters. (Single Player Only) |
| Of all the inquisitive Hobbits. (Bronze) | Unlock all the Map Stones in Middle-earth. (Single Player Only) |
| On the Precious... (Bronze) | Complete 'Taming Gollum'. |
| One does not simply... (Bronze) | Walk into Mordor. |
| One Ring to build them all. (Platinum) | Collect every trophy. |
| Our only wish to catch a fish! (Bronze) | Fish perfectly 20 times by pressing the icon as it flashes. |
| Pointy-eared Elvish princeling. (Bronze) | Defeat 42 Uruk-hai as Legolas. |
| Ready for another adventure. (Silver) | Achieve True Adventurer in every level. (Single Player Only) |
| Return of the Mushroom King. (Bronze) | Equip Aragorn with the Mushroom Crown. |
| Safe is where I'll keep you. (Bronze) | Complete 'Track Hobbits'. |
| Soft and quick as shadows... (Bronze) | Complete 'The Dead Marshes'. |
| Stinking creatures... (Bronze) | Complete 'Warg Attack'. |
| Taking the Hobbits to Isengard. (Bronze) | Travel to Isengard as every playable Hobbit. |
| That is a rare gift. (Bronze) | Reach the top of Amon Hen without being caught once by Boromir. (Single Player Only) |
| That is no trinket you carry. (Bronze) | Complete 'Weathertop'. |
| That one counts as mine! (Bronze) | Finish one of Gimli's opponents as Legolas in 'Helm's Deep'. |
| That still only counts as one! (Bronze) | Defeat an Oliphaunt as Legolas. |
| The battle is about to begin... (Bronze) | Complete 'Helm's Deep'. |
| The long way around. (Bronze) | Complete 'The Pass of Caradhras'. |
| The Lord of the Ring. (Silver) | Complete the Bonus Level. |
| The strength of Men failed. (Bronze) | Complete 'Prologue'. |
| There and Back Again. (Gold) | Get 100%. (Single Player Only) |
| There's some good in this world. (Gold) | Complete all the Fetch Quests in Middle-earth. (Single Player Only) |
| They have been summoned. (Bronze) | Complete 'The Paths of the Dead'. |
| This day we fight! (Bronze) | Complete 'The Black Gate'. |
| This is no mine... it's a tomb. (Bronze) | Complete 'The Mines of Moria'. |
| We cannot linger. (Bronze) | Complete 'The Mines of Moria' in under 15 minutes. |
| We did it, Mr. Frodo. (Bronze) | Complete 'Cirith Ungol'. |
| What about second breakfast? (Bronze) | Complete 2 cooking puzzles. |
| Worth greater than the Shire. (Bronze) | Dress a character completely in treasure items. |
| You and whose army? (Bronze) | Complete 'The Battle of Pelennor Fields'. |
.