There are 38 Bronze Trophies, 5 Silver Trophies, 3 Gold Trophies, and 1 Platinum Trophy.
| Unlockable: | How to unlock: |
| A Few Hundred Bullets Back (Bronze) | Use Every Weapon In The Game |
| A License To Kill (Silver) | Collect All Golden Guns |
| A New York Minute (Gold) | Finish In A New York Minute |
| All Of The Above (Gold) | Finish All Single Player Grinds |
| Along For The Ride (Bronze) | Trigger A Bullet Cam On The Zipline [FREE AIM] |
| Amidst The Wreckage (Bronze) | Destroy All The Models In The Boardroom |
| An Echo Of The Past (Bronze) | Find All Clues |
| Colder Than The Devil's Heart (Bronze) | Kill 30 Enemies In 2 Minutes |
| Dearest Of All My Friends (Bronze) | Kill Someone On Your Friends List |
| Deathmatch Challenge (Bronze) | Winner In Any Public Deathmatch |
| Feel The Payne (Bronze) | Story Complete [MEDIUM] |
| Full Monty (Bronze) | Complete One Of Each Game Mode Including All Gang Wars |
| Grave Robber (Bronze) | Looted A Body |
| It Was Chaos And Luck (Bronze) | Get 6 Kills While Riding The Push Cart [FREE AIM] |
| It's Fear That Gives Men Wings (Bronze) | 10 Bullet TimeŽ Kills In A Row |
| Man Of Many Faces (Bronze) | Unlock All Faction Characters |
| Man Of Many Weapons (Bronze) | Unlock All Weapons |
| Max Payne Invitational (Bronze) | Invite someone to play through the in-game contact list |
| Maximum Payne (Gold) | Story Complete [OLD SCHOOL] |
| One Bullet At A Time (Bronze) | 300 Headshots |
| Out The Window (Bronze) | Get 6 Kills While Diving Through The VIP Window [FREE AIM] |
| Part I Complete (Bronze) | Complete Part I Of The Story |
| Part II Complete (Bronze) | Complete Part II Of The Story |
| Part III Complete (Bronze) | Complete Part III Of The Story |
| Past The Point Of No Return (Bronze) | Take 100 Painkillers |
| Payne Bringer (Silver) | Kill 100 Other Players |
| Payne In The Ass (Bronze) | Story Complete [HARDCORE] |
| Platinum Trophy (Platinum) | Unlock All Max Payne 3 Trophies |
| Serious Payne (Silver) | Story Complete [HARD] |
| So Much For Being Subtle (Bronze) | Get 9 Kills While Being Pulled By A Chain [FREE AIM] |
| Something Wicked This Way Comes (Bronze) | Get 7 Kills While Jumping From The Rickety Boat [FREE AIM] |
| Sometimes You Get Lucky (Bronze) | Get A Headshot During The Rooftop Tremors |
| That Old Familiar Feeling (Bronze) | Clear The Hallway Of Lasers |
| The Fear Of Losing It (Bronze) | Survive A Level Without Painkillers |
| The Gambler (Bronze) | Won A Wager |
| The One Eyed Man Is King (Bronze) | Cover Passos With Perfect Aim |
| The Only Choice Given (Bronze) | Get 8 Kills While Dangling From A Chain [FREE AIM] |
| The Road-Kill Behind Me (Bronze) | Total Everything On The Runway |
| The Shadows Rushed Me (Silver) | Unlock And Complete New York Minute Hardcore |
| Training Complete (Silver) | Achieve Level Rank 50 |
| Trouble Had Come To Me (Bronze) | Clear Everyone On The Bus Ride |
| With Practiced Bravado (Bronze) | 100 Kills During Shootdodge |
| You Might Hurt Someone With That (Bronze) | Shoot 10 Airborne Grenades |
| You Play, You Pay, You Bastard (Bronze) | 100 Kills With Melee |
| You Sure Know How To Pick A Place (Bronze) | Discover All Tourist Locations |
