There are 17 Bronze Trophies, 9 Silver Trophies, 5 Gold Trophies, and 1 Platinum Trophy.
| Unlockable: | How to unlock: |
| 2-Out Rally | Score 3+runs after 1st 2 batters of inning made outs(not achievable in RTTS;earned if playing uninterrupted game against CPU,w/o switch sides or ffing |
| Bronze |
| Arr, Matey! | In PNC Park™ (PIT), hit a home run that hits the PIRATES hedge in center field (on the fly). |
| Bronze |
| Average Boost | Get 5 hits in a single game, with a single player (only earned if playing an uninterrupted game against the CPU, without switching sides or ffing). |
| Silver |
| Bang the Drum | In Turner Field™ (ATL), hit a home run to center field that hits the bongo drum (on the fly). |
| Gold |
| Brand New Ballgame | Tie score after being down by 4 runs in game(not achievable in RTTS;only earned if playing uninterrupted game against CPU,w/o switching sides or ffing |
| Silver |
| Brewed Fresh | In Miller Park™ (MIL), hit a home run in the stands to the right of the center field hitter's eye (on the fly). |
| Silver |
| Bringing the Heat | Earn save by throwing all fastballs(1 & 2-out saves don't qualify;earned if playing uninterrupted 9-inning game against CPU,w/o switching sides or ff |
| Bronze |
| Bronx Bomber | In Yankee Stadium™ (NYY), hit a home run into the second deck of the right field stands (excludes classic stadiums). |
| Bronze |
| Credit Extension | In Citi Field™ (NYM), have a player hit for the cycle (only earned if playing an uninterrupted game against the CPU, without switching sides or ffing) |
| Gold |
| Derby King | Win an Online Home Run Derby™ contest. |
| Bronze |
| Didn't Even Break a Sweat | Have your strt pitcher throw complete game w/58 or less pitch thrown(earn if playing uninterrupted 9-inning game against CPU,w/o switching sides or ff |
| Gold |
| Disrespected | Hit a home run immediately after an intentional walk (only earned if playing an uninterrupted game against the CPU, without switching sides or ffing). |
| Bronze |
| Dreaded Leadoff Walk | Draw a walk with the first hitter of an inning (only earned if playing an uninterrupted game against the CPU, without switching sides or ffing). |
| Bronze |
| Escape Artist | As pitcher,escape from no out,bases loaded jam w/o any runners scoring(earned if playing uninterrupted game against CPU,w/o switching sides or ffing). |
| Silver |
| Fall Ball | Complete a Postseason Mode game (only earned if playing an uninterrupted 9-inning game against the CPU, without switching sides or fast forwarding). |
| Bronze |
| First Person | In Road to the Show, catch a fly ball using the new Manual Catch feature. |
| Bronze |
| First Steps | Advance to Beginner Hitting Rank 2(unachievable in Practice or Training modes;earn if playing uninterrupted game against CPU,w/o switching sides or ff |
| Bronze |
| Going Green | Use the Card Recycler in Diamond Dynasty. |
| Bronze |
| Hail to the Chief | In Nationals Park™ (WAS), hit a home run off the right field foul pole. |
| Silver |
| In the Books | Earn all of the MLB® 13 The Show™ Trophies. |
| Platinum |
| Land Ho! | In Safeco Field™ (SEA), hit a home run into the bullpens in left-center that lands on dirt. |
| Silver |
| Latest and Greatest | Complete a The Show™ Live game (only earned if playing an uninterrupted 9-inning game against the CPU, without switching sides or fast forwarding). |
| Bronze |
| Number 17 | In sngl game, hit 4+ h/rs w/same player(unachievable in Home Run Derby™;earn if playing uninterrupted game against CPU,w/o switching sides or ffing). |
| Gold |
| Payback Time | After getting hit by pitch,hit home run on that player's following at-bat(earn if playing uninterrupted game against CPU,w/o switching sides or ffing) |
| Silver |
| Piling On | In single game,score 20 or more runs(not achievable in RTTS;only earned if playing uninterrupted game against CPU,w/o switching sides or ffing). |
| Silver |
| Quick Thinking | Pull off successful 1-2-3 double play(not achievable in RTTS;only earned if playing uninterrupted game against CPU, without switching sides or ffing). |
| Bronze |
| Sitting Dead Red | Hit a home run after having successfully guessed fastball (only earned if playing an uninterrupted game against the CPU, without switching sides or ff |
| Bronze |
| Small Ball | Runner on 2nd and/or 3rd w/0 outs,hit grnd out to->side of field that advance runner(s)(earn if play uninterrupted game againstCPU,w/o switching or ff |
| Bronze |
| So Close, Yet... | In Oriole Park (BAL), hit the scoreboard in right field (on the fly, in fair territory). |
| Bronze |
| Strike ‘Em Out, Throw ‘Em Out | Turn dbl play by strikeout batter&throwout runner stealing(unachievable inRTTS;earn if playing uninterrupted game againstCPU,w/o switching sides or ff |
| Bronze |
| Winning Combo | Throw combined no-hitter w/2+ pitchers(not achievable in RTTS;only earned if playing uninterrupted 9-inning game against CPU,w/o switching sides or ff |
| Gold |
| Worm Killer | As pitcher,induce 15 or more ground outs in single game(only earned if playing uninterrupted game against the CPU, without switching sides or ffing). |
.