There are 39 Bronze Trophies, 9 Silver Trophies, 2 Gold Trophies, and 1 Platinum Trophy.
| Unlockable: | How to unlock: |
| 2-Peat | Win Back to Back World Series® in My Player Mode. |
| Silver |
| A Job Well Done | Win 100+ games in a season in My Player Mode. |
| Silver |
| A Pitcher's Best Friend | Turn a double play in a non-simulated game. |
| Bronze |
| A Virtue | Face 10 pitches as the batter in a non-simulated game. |
| Silver |
| Almost There | Hit 37 triples with your user profile. |
| Bronze |
| As Good as a Hit | Walk 233 times with your user profile. |
| Silver |
| Back to the Cage | Get a Golden Sombrero (strikeout 4 times in 1 game) in My Player Mode. |
| Bronze |
| Chicks Dig It | Hit 74 home runs with your user profile. |
| Bronze |
| Count it | Complete and win a ranked match. |
| Bronze |
| Domination | Save 63 games with your user profile. |
| Bronze |
| Don't Call it a Comeback | Win after being down by 4 after the 6th inning in a non-simulated game. |
| Bronze |
| Down But Not Out | Get a hit with 2 strikes in a non-simulated game. |
| Bronze |
| Dual Threat | Steal a base with a pitcher in a non-simulated game. |
| Bronze |
| Fanning the Flames | Strike out 514 batters with your user profile. |
| Bronze |
| Grab Some Pine | Get a strikeout to end the inning in a non-simulated game. |
| Bronze |
| He Taketh Away | Rob a Home Run by climbing the wall in a non-simulated game. |
| Bronze |
| Home, Sweet Home | Score 193 runs with your user profile. |
| Bronze |
| I Came, I Saw... | Hit a Walk-off Home Run in a non-simulated game. |
| Bronze |
| King of the Hill | Get to the top of the Best of the Best ladder in Home Run Derby® Mode. |
| Bronze |
| Mr. Consistency | Get a hit in all 9 innings in a non-simulated game. |
| Silver |
| My Fellow Man | Complete and win an online game. |
| Bronze |
| My Main Squeeze | Bunt the man home in a non-simulated game. |
| Bronze |
| No Hole too Deep | Battle Back: Down 0-2, get walked in a non-simulated game. |
| Bronze |
| One Man Show | Throw a No-Hitter in a 9 inning, non-simulated game. |
| Gold |
| Payback | Hit a home run off a former team in My Player Mode. |
| Bronze |
| Production | Drive in 192 RBI with your user profile. |
| Bronze |
| Productivity | Get 263 hits with your user profile. |
| Bronze |
| Remember Me | Break a record in Franchise Mode. (play at least 20 games) |
| Bronze |
| Set the Table | Hit 68 doubles with your user profile. |
| Bronze |
| Stooges | Strikeout all three hitters in the inning in a non-simulated game. |
| Bronze |
| Take That | Get an RBI after getting brushed back off the plate in a non-simulated game. |
| Bronze |
| The Call | Get called up to the Majors in My Player Mode. |
| Bronze |
| The Champs | Win a World Series® in Franchise Mode. (play at least 20 games) |
| Silver |
| The Goal | Accomplish a Team Season Goal in My Player Mode. |
| Bronze |
| The Hall | Make the Hall of Fame in My Player Mode. |
| Silver |
| The Road to Greatness | Complete and win 3 ranked matches in a row. |
| Bronze |
| The Road to Victory | Get 3 consecutive batters on base in a non-simulated game. |
| Bronze |
| The Spice of Life | Play 10 ranked matches using 10 different teams. |
| Bronze |
| The Star | Make the All-Star team in My Player Mode. |
| Silver |
| The Start of Something Special | Lead off an inning by hitting a triple in a non-simulated game. |
| Bronze |
| The Team to Beat | Beat the San Francisco Giants™ in a completed online match. |
| Bronze |
| The Top | Become the #1 ranked player in your My Player organization. |
| Silver |
| This is Why I'm Here | Be successful in a major league clutch moment in My Player Mode. |
| Bronze |
| Throw First and Aim Later | Miss your throw to first base with 2 outs in a non-simulated game. |
| Bronze |
| To the Rescue | Get a save with the tying run on base in a non-simulated game. |
| Bronze |
| Upset Alert | Use the Houston Astros™ in a completed ranked match. |
| Bronze |
| Walk Off | Unlock all Trophies |
| Platinum |
| What's Your Ring Size? | Win a World Series® in My Player Mode. |
| Gold |
| You Make Your Own Destiny | Steal 139 bases with your user profile. |
| Bronze |
| You're Special | Win a Season award in Franchise Mode. (play at least 20 games) |
| Bronze |
| Your Day | Win player of the game in an MLB game in My Player Mode. |
.