There are 35 Bronze Trophies, 9 Silver Trophies, 2 Gold Trophies, and 1 Platinum Trophy.
| Unlockable: | How to unlock: |
| After Market (Bronze) | Unlock a mod for a car in Multiplayer |
| Alpha Dog (Bronze) | Shut down Most Wanted car number 10: Alfa Romeo 4C Concept (Single Player) |
| Arachnophobic (Bronze) | Shut down Most Wanted car number 5: Porsche 918 Spyder Concept (Single Player) |
| Battering Ram (Bronze) | Smash through a roadblock without crashing |
| Beast from the East (Silver) | Escape from the cops in the Marussia B2 |
| Blackout (Bronze) | Shut down Most Wanted car number 8: Mercedes-Benz SL 65 AMG (Single Player) |
| Cameraman (Bronze) | Trigger every Speed Camera |
| Charming (Bronze) | Shut down Most Wanted car number 9: Shelby COBRA 427® (Single Player) |
| Don't Blink (Silver) | Shut down Most Wanted car number 1: Koenigsegg Agera R (Single Player) |
| Escape Velocity (Bronze) | Jump over 200 yards (182.88 meters) through a Billboard |
| Fast Forward (Bronze) | Trigger a speed camera at over 200mph (321.97km/h) |
| Feeling the Need (Bronze) | Empty a full nitrous bar without hitting anything |
| First Strike (Bronze) | Takedown your first Cop |
| Fix Me Up (Bronze) | Use a Bodyshop to paint or repair your car for the first time |
| Gladiator (Silver) | Takedown every racer at least once in a single race |
| Go Pro or Go Home (Bronze) | Unlock all the Pro mods on a car (Single Player) |
| Got to Smash Them All (Bronze) | Smash every Billboard |
| Gotcha (Bronze) | Get Busted for the first time |
| How Do You Like Me Now? (Bronze) | Beat a friend's Autolog Recommendation |
| In Your Face (Bronze) | Smash a friend's face on a billboard and beat their jump distance |
| Iron Boots (Bronze) | Drive over 5 spike strips with re-inflates equipped |
| Kitchen Sink (Bronze) | Use a Billboard and a Jack Spot to successfully evade a pursuit (Single Player) |
| Lexus Ranger (Bronze) | Shut down Most Wanted car number 7: Lexus LFA (Single Player) |
| Licensed to ill (Silver) | Customize your license plate and number in Multiplayer |
| Love Them and Leave Them (Bronze) | Drive every Car |
| Main Avent (Bronze) | Shut down Most Wanted car number 4: Lamborghini Aventador (Single Player) |
| Mauled (Silver) | Wreck 10 cops in a single pursuit in the Ford F-150 SVT Raptor |
| Mighty Wind (Bronze) | Shut down Most Wanted car number 2: Pagani Huayra (Single Player) |
| Mix Master (Bronze) | Play a Custom Speedlist you have created (Multiplayer) |
| Most Wanted Rides (Gold) | Own all the Most Wanted cars (Single Player) |
| Moving On Up (Bronze) | Move up the Most Wanted List for the first time |
| Networking (Bronze) | Find every Jack Spot |
| None More Wanted (Platinum) | Awarded for successfully collecting all Most Wanted trophies |
| Nothing Personal (Bronze) | Takedown a friend in Multiplayer |
| Pit Stop (Bronze) | Repair a burst tire at a Bodyshop |
| Rim Shot (Silver) | Escape the cops with at least one blown tire |
| Second is Nothing (Gold) | Finish first in every race, in every car (Single Player) |
| Sidewinder (Bronze) | Do a 250 yard (228.6 meter) drift |
| Slip the Cuffs (Bronze) | Drive through a roadblock without hitting it |
| Social Climber (Bronze) | Get 5 or more NFS friends |
| Switcheroo (Bronze) | Use a Jack Spot in a Pursuit (Single Player) |
| The Gatecrasher (Bronze) | Break through every Security Gate |
| The Heat is Off (Silver) | Escape successfully from all Heat levels |
| The Modfather (Silver) | Unlock 3 Pro Mods in Multiplayer |
| Track Weapon (Bronze) | Shut down Most Wanted car number 6: McLaren MP4-12C (Single Player) |
| Troublemaker (Silver) | Takedown 50 Cops |
| White Gold (Bronze) | Shut down Most Wanted car number 3: Bugatti Veyron Super Sport (Single Player) |
