There are 37 Bronze Trophies, 10 Silver Trophies, 2 Gold Trophies, and 1 Platinum Trophy.
| Unlockable: | How to unlock: |
| Bed Blaster (Bronze) | Destroy all beds that lead to Pitch's Realm portal. |
| Belief Spin (Bronze) | Turn the Globe of Belief 360 degrees on the Pause Screen. |
| Believe in the Magic (Bronze) | Level up for the first time. |
| Beyond Belief (Silver) | Defeat Pitch in the Final Showdown and reach 100% world belief. |
| Celebrate Your Center (Silver) | Complete all Find Your Center missions in each realm. |
| Co-op Captain (Bronze) | Instigate a co-operative attack move. |
| Cold Warrior (Bronze) | Upgrade your weapon to Level 4. |
| Cool Headed (Bronze) | Upgrade your weapon to Level 2. |
| Crystal Champ (Bronze) | Collect 15000 Crystals. |
| Deliver Holiday Cheer (Bronze) | Perform a 10 point combo. |
| Dig the Spring (Bronze) | Find and Collect all Painted Eggs scattered across all 5 realms. |
| Dreamer (Bronze) | Find and Collect all Dreamsand Capsules scattered across all 5 realms. |
| Elite Guardian (Silver) | Reach Valor Level 20. |
| Eternally Chill (Bronze) | Find and Collect all Snowballs scattered across all 5 realms. |
| Explorer - Bunnymund's Warren (Bronze) | Travel to The Warren by way of a Guardian Gate. |
| Explorer - Burgess (Bronze) | Travel to Burgess by way of a Guardian Gate. |
| Explorer - North Pole (Bronze) | Travel to the North Pole by way of a Guardian Gate. |
| Explorer - Pitch's Lair (Bronze) | Enter Pitch's Lair for the first time. |
| Explorer - Sandman's Ship (Bronze) | Travel to the Sandman's Ship by way of a Guardian Gate. |
| Explorer - Tooth's Palace (Bronze) | Travel to Tooth's Palace by way of a Guardian Gate. |
| Friends to the Rescue (Silver) | Complete all Cage Break missions in each realm. |
| Gates of Bunnymund's Warren (Bronze) | Reclaim all gates at The Warren. |
| Gates of Burgess (Bronze) | Reclaim all gates at Burgess. |
| Gates of Sandman's Ship (Bronze) | Reclaim all gates at the Sandman's Ship. |
| Gates of the North Pole (Bronze) | Reclaim all gates at the North Pole. |
| Gates of Tooth's Palace (Bronze) | Reclaim all gates at Tooth's Palace. |
| Glory of the Guardians (Gold) | Defeat Pitch at the Final Showdown in Burgess. |
| Gone Fishing (Bronze) | Destroy all 5 instances of fishing gear around the lake. |
| Guardian Explorer (Silver) | Travel to each realm in the whole world. |
| Guardians Deliver (Gold) | Reach 100% World Belief. |
| Guardians Unite (Silver) | Complete all Protectors of Belief missions in each realm. |
| I Still Believe (Silver) | Defeat Pitch in each of the five confrontations. |
| Ice Cold (Bronze) | Upgrade your weapon to Level 3. |
| Keeper of the Gates (Silver) | Complete all Gate Guardians missions in each realm. |
| Magic is Everywhere (Bronze) | Destroy all Nightmares in all realms. |
| Memories are Treasures (Bronze) | Destroy the circle of mushrooms in Tooth's Asia Temple. |
| Memories Safe (Bronze) | Find and Collect all Tooth Boxes scattered across all 5 realms. |
| My Kind of Element (Bronze) | Purchase all Gems. |
| Never Stop Believing (Bronze) | Reach a 50 point combo. |
| Nightmares Beware (Silver) | Complete all Shadow Stompers missions in each realm. |
| Riding the Wind (Bronze) | Hit 10 Mailboxes around the streets of Burgess. |
| Rise of the Guardians (Platinum) | Earn all trophies to unlock this platinum trophy. |
| Shadow Sifter (Bronze) | Destroy one of each type of Champion Nightmare. |
| Shadow Spree (Bronze) | Destroy 100 Nightmare enemies. |
| Shadow Take-Down (Bronze) | Destroy one of each Nightmare enemy. |
| This is Going to be Epic! (Silver) | Defeat Pitch for the fifth and final time in his Lair. |
| Tis' the Season to be Naughty (Bronze) | Destroy 40 piles of presents in North's Factory. |
| Toy Central (Bronze) | Find and Collect all Wooden Toys scattered across all 5 realms. |
| Workin' Hard Every Day (Bronze) | Destroy 20 vases in Tooth's realm. |
| Yeti Master (Bronze) | Hit a friendly Yeti ten times. |
.