There are 36 Bronze Trophies, 10 Silver Trophies, 2 Gold Trophies, and 1 Platinum Trophy.
| Unlockable: | How to unlock: |
| A fresh beginning (Bronze) | Play in an Online match (Player match/Ranked match) |
| A legend begins (Bronze) | Win at least one match on Hard difficulty or higher (single player). |
| A man who wastes no opportunity (Silver) | Cash in a Money in the Bank and win using a Custom Superstar in WWE Universe (single player). |
| A once in a lifetime event (Bronze) | Appear in WrestleMania using a Custom Superstar in WWE Universe (single player) |
| A Superstar is born! (Bronze) | Win a match using a Custom Superstar in WWE Universe mode (single player). |
| A winner is you! (Bronze) | Win 10 ranked matches. |
| A winning combination! (Bronze) | Use a wake-up taunt, land a Finisher and immediately pin your opponent (single player). |
| All original baby! (Bronze) | Compete as a Custom Superstar in a Custom Arena for a Custom Championship. |
| Arena designer (Bronze) | Create an arena in Create an Arena mode. |
| Awesome! (Bronze) | Take a screenshot in Create a Highlight mode. |
| Berserker (Bronze) | Break a total of 50 tables, ladders, and chairs by attacking with them (single player). |
| Check out my Entrance Video! (Bronze) | Create an entrance movie in Create an Entrance mode |
| Comeback! (Bronze) | Successfully perform a Comeback Move (single player). |
| Create and destroy (Bronze) | Exhibition (Title Match) - Attack your opponent with a custom belt (single player). |
| Critic (Bronze) | Review 5 or more user-created content items in Community Creations. |
| Established veteran (Silver) | Achieve the rank 10 online. |
| Fighting smart (Bronze) | Exhibition - Attack the same body part 10 or more times in a single match (single player). |
| Gold standard (Silver) | Earn the WWE, WCW, and ECW Championship belts with a single Superstar. |
| I just keep evolving! (Bronze) | Exhibition (Legend difficulty) - With a Superstar, defeat his Attitude Era version (single player). |
| Invincible man (Silver) | Win at least 20 matches on Hard difficulty or higher (single player). |
| King of the world (Gold) | Achieve the maximum rank online. |
| Made-up original story (Bronze) | Create a story including a Custom Superstar or a Custom Arena. |
| Mr. Money in the Bank (Silver) | Win Money in the Bank using a Custom Superstar in WWE Universe mode (single player). |
| Negotiatior (Bronze) | Exhibition - Force an opponent to quit in an "I Quit" Match (single player). |
| One of history's greats (Bronze) | Exhibition (Legend difficulty) - Defeat a Superstar with his Attitude Era version (single player). |
| Paint tool magician (Bronze) | Use the paint tool to create and add an original logo to any original creation. |
| Platinum (Platinum) | Obtain all other Trophies. |
| Reached the ropes! (Bronze) | Crawl to the ropes during a submission (Single Player). |
| Ring hooligan (Bronze) | Break a total of 20 tables, ladders, and chairs by attacking with them (single player). |
| Rising star (Bronze) | Achieve the rank 5 online. |
| The champ is here! (Bronze) | Create an original championship belt in the Championship Editor. |
| The ring is my home! (Bronze) | Play a match in an arena created in Create an Arena mode. |
| The Streak Ends (Gold) | Beat The Undertaker at WrestleMania with a Custom Superstar on Legend difficulty (single player). |
| This is special! (Bronze) | Create a front, top-rope, and corner special move. |
| Welcome to the creators' circle (Bronze) | Your Community Creations content has been reviewed at least 5 times. |
.