Complete each achievement to get the allotted gamerscore.
| Unlockable: | How to unlock: |
| Throw 4 TD Passes in a Game (15) | Throw 4 touchdown passes in a single Play Now or Dynasty Mode game. |
| 350 Total Passing Yards (15) | Pass for 350 or more total yards in a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game. |
| 200 Total Rushing Yards (15) | Rush for 200 or more total yards in a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game. |
| Player Passing Record in a Game (25) | Break the game record for passing yards with one player (716) in a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game. |
| No Interceptions in a Game (15) | Do not throw any interceptions in a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game. |
| Win by 21 (10) | Win a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game by 21 points or more. |
| Pass to 5 Different Receivers (10) | Complete a pass to 5 or more different receivers in a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game. |
| 100 Yard Receiver (10) | Gain 100 or more receiving yards with a single player in a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game. |
| 100 Yard Rusher (10) | Rush for 100 or more yards with a single player in a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game. |
| Complete a 30 Yard Pass (10) | Complete a pass for 30 or more yards in a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game. |
| Complete a 60 Yard Pass (20) | Complete a pass for 60 or more yards in a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game. |
| Break a 30 Yard Run (10) | Break a run for 30 or more yards in a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game. |
| Break a 60 Yard Run (20) | Break a run for 60 or more yards in a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game. |
| Allow No Sacks (15) | Do not give up any sacks in a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game. |
| Score 35 Points (15) | Score 35 points or more in a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game. |
| Player Rushing Record in a Game (25) | Break the game record for rushing yards with one player (406) in a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game. |
