Complete each achievement to get the allotted gamerscore.
| Unlockable: | How to unlock: |
| Intercept 2 Passes (15) | ntercept 2 passes in a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game. |
| Player Interception Record (25) | Break the game record for interceptions with one player (5) in a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game. |
| Return Interception for a TD (20) | Return an interception for a touchdown on defense in a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game. |
| Return Fumble for TD (20) | Score a touchdown after recovering a fumble on defense in a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game. |
| Make 4 Sacks (20) | Sack the opposing quarterback 4 or more times in a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game. |
| Pontiac 4th Quarter Comeback (30) | Win a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game when down by 14 to start the 4th qtr. (Min Difficulty: Varsity) |
| Old Spice Red Zone Shutout (20) | Complete a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game without giving up a touchdown while in the Red Zone. |
| Old Spice Red Zone Perfection (15) | Complete a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game with a Red Zone Efficiency rating of 100%. |
| Fill Up Legend Meter (30) | Completely fill up the legend meter. |
| 5-Star Legend Prospect (20) | Create a 5-star legend prospect. |
| High Score - Option Dash (30) | Score 15,000 or more points in Option Dash. |
| Win Tug-of-War (30) | Win the Tug-of-War mini-game. |
| Perfect Game (30) | Bowl a 300 Game in a single player Bowling Mini-Game. |
| Held Under 200 Yards (10) | Hold the opposition to under 200 total yards in a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game. |
| Held Under 100 Yards (25) | Hold the opposition to under 100 total yards in a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game. |
| 2 Sack Player (10) | Make 2 sacks in a Play Now or Dynasty Mode game with the same player. |
