Complete each achievement to get the allotted gamerscore.
| Unlockable: | How to unlock: |
| National League All-Star (75) | Complete Rookie Challenge with any National League team. |
| Reach For The Stars (50) | In Rookie Challenge, get 5 stars in all of your rookie's attributes. |
| Party like it's 1881! (50) | Get a Grand Slam in any single player game mode. |
| Pain Train (15) | Runner collides with the catcher receiving a throw at home plate in any single player game mode. |
| 20 Runs (30) | Score 20 runs in one game in any single player game mode. |
| 15 Runs (25) | Score 15 runs in one game in any single player game mode. |
| 10 Runs (20) | Score 10 runs in one game in any single player game mode. |
| 7 Runs (15) | Score 7 runs in one game in any single player game mode. |
| 5 Runs (10) | Score 5 runs in one game in any single player game mode. |
| 3 Runs (5) | Score 3 runs in one game in any single player game mode. |
| He's on fire! (50) | Throw 15 perfect pitches in a row in any single player game mode. |
| Hot streak (20) | Throw 10 perfect pitches in a row in any single player game mode. |
| Throw 10 perfect pitches in a row in any single player game mode. | Complete Rookie Challenge with any American League team. |
| Penultimate Perfection (75) | In a 9 inning single player game, prevent the other team from getting an official hit. |
| Textbook Perfection (100) | In a 9 inning single player game, prevent the other team from getting on base at all. |
| 100,000 Points (5) | Get 100,000 points in Home Run Pinball. |
